The Patriots travel to San Diego this week to face the Chargers in the divisional round of the playoffs. The Chargers are the best team in football, went 14-2 in the regular season, are full of all-pro players, and have the best player in the (history of?) the league in RB LaDainain Tomlinson. The Patriots will need to have a perfect gameplan and perfect execution to win this game. Let’s take a further look at what they have to do.
The key on defense is stopping LaDainian Tomlinson. In three career games against the Pats, he’s averaged over 140 yards. But those were against different teams (for example, last year, when Wilfork was playing poorly, Monty Beisel and Chad Brown were our middle linebackers, and we had just lost Rodney Harrison). With the way our defensive line of Ty Warren, Vince Wilfork, and Richard Seymour have been playing lately, we should have a chance at stopping. But can we?
Tomlinson was held under 100 yards in five games this year. Four in a row early against Baltimore, Pittsburgh, San Francisco, and Kansas City (their only two losses came in this 4 game stretch) and the final game against Arizona. The Chargers only played 2 teams all year that are in the top 10 in run defense (Baltimore and Pittsburgh) and Tomlinson was held up 100 yards in both games. The Pats D is ranked 5th, only giving up 94.2 rush yards per game.
So it seems likely that we can stop the run. But what do we have to sacrifice to do it? If we bring 8 men in the box to stop the run, it may be pretty easy for TE Antonio Gates (the best TE in the league) to get open. Baltimore was able to hold Rivers to 145 yards passing in that game (part of that is Schottenhemier playing Martyball and sitting on the ball in the 2nd half). Other teams were not as lucky as Rivers passed for over 230 yards in each of the other games were Tomlinson was stopped.
I think the Pats defense has to try to stop Tomlinson using their front seven so they still have the ability to stop the pass as well. It would be even better if we could get an early lead to put them in passing situations even more. Then hopefully we can force QB Philip Rivers (first year as a starter) into some mistakes (a la Ben Roethlisburger in the 2004 AFC Championship Game). Rivers only has 9 interceptions on the year, but 4 of the 9 were in those 5 games were Tomlinson was held under 100 yards.
The Patriots defense is also #2 in the league after Baltimore in opponent QB rating. Other than Baltimore, SD also played seventh ranked Oakland and ninth ranked Denver twice. Rivers threw 2 picks at Denver, 1 at home against Oakland, and 1 against Baltimore.
Now let’s look at the other side of the ball. The Chargers play a 3-4 defense similar to the Pats and have a huge nose tackle Jamal Williams like our Vince Wilfork. They also have one of the best pass rushers in football in LB Shaun Merriman. San Diego is first in the league in sacks and 11th in opponent passer rating. When playing teams with similar sack-happy defenses (Miami and Green Bay), the Patriots allowed 1 and 5 sacks to the Dolphins and 2 sacks to the Packers. Since that 5 sack Dolphins game (a 21-0 loss), the Patriots have worked a lot harder on their protection and only given up 5 sacks in the last 4 games.
Points-wise, the Chargers defense has not faced an offense as good as the Patriots (averaging 24.1 pts/game). In terms of yards, the Steelers and Bengals are better offenses than the Patriots and the Chargers gave up only 13 to the Steelers but 41 to the Bengals. In passer rating, the Bengals are higher rated than the Pats offense and the Chiefs, Ravens, and Bills are rated just behind the Pats. The Chargers gave up 41 to the Bengals, 30 (in a loss) and 9 to the Chiefs, 16 to the Ravens, and 21 to the Bills in a very close 24-21 win.
So although I was pretty worried about the matchup of the Pats O and the Chargers D, I think the Patriots have a good chance to put up some points on them. If the Pats can stay out of pass situations like 3rd and long and throw some quick passes to avoid the blitz pressure then they should be OK.
On special teams, the Patriots are first in kickoff returns and third in punt returns against the SD coverage units which are 12th on kickoffs and 15th on punts. San Diego is 3rd in kickoff returns and 17th in punt returns while the Patriots are 20th in kickoff coverage and 26th in punt coverage. So the Patriots have to be concerned about their coverage units but do have a shot at breaking some long returns.
As for intangibles, Belichick and the team are battle-tested, playoff veterans and will be prepared for any situation. The Chargers lost their last playoff game in 2004, have a QB in his first year as a starter, and a coach who has a bad playoff reputation and who reportedly will be fired if they lose. Also, the Patriots are the underdog which always motivates them and their wide receiving corps should be pretty pumped after Florida wrecked Ohio State for the BCS Championship (4 of the Pats receivers are from Florida - Reche Caldwell, Jabar Gaffney, Chad Jackson, and Kelvin Kight).
I think the key thing in this game, on both sides of the ball, will be whether teams get into passing situations. The Patriots want to get an early lead and stop Tomlinson on early downs to force the Chargers and Rivers into more passing situations. More passing situations would mean less worry of Tomlinson running on them and more chances of forcing Philip Rivers into mistakes. Similarly, on offense, the Patriots want to have the luxury of being able to run the ball, meaning having an early lead and getting some good yards on first and second down to avoid 3rd and long situations where Merriman and company can blitz.
Here is my prediction: The Patriots return the opening kickoff for a touchdown. This gives them some momentum and the early lead. The defensive line is able to contain Tomlinson, holding him to 90 or so yards. The Patriots force Philip Rivers into one or two turnovers and the Pats’ offense does not turn the ball over. Patriots win 27-20.